StillGood?
/
USDA-based guidance

Pies

Pumpkin, pecan, custard, and chiffon pies are egg or dairy fillings that belong in the refrigerator after they cool — not on the counter for days. Open the pie page that matches your dessert for chart numbers. Past a fridge window, discard it. Fridge = safety; freezer = quality.
Pumpkin Pie fridge 3–4 days · freezer Quality varies — verify exact timing standard windows Egg/dairy pumpkin custard — refrigerate promptly after cooling. Pecan Pie fridge 3–4 days · freezer 1–2 months standard windows Egg-rich filling — refrigerate; do not leave on the counter for days. Custard Pie fridge 3–4 days · freezer Quality varies — verify exact timing standard windows Custard or cream filling — must be refrigerated. Chiffon Pie fridge 1–2 days · freezer Quality varies — verify exact timing spoils fast — refrigerate Egg-foam chiffon filling — refrigerate; fragile texture.

Fridge vs freezer

FoodSafety.gov lists pumpkin, pecan, custard, and chiffon pies with a short refrigerator safety window. Fruit pies without egg/dairy custard are a different category and are not covered by this hub. Freezer guidance on those rows is about quality if you freeze at all — check the individual page rather than assuming every pie freezes well.

How to tell a pie is spoiled

Sour smell, weeping watery filling, mold on the surface or crust edge, or a slimy custard layer means discard it. Egg-based fillings can support pathogen growth when left in the danger zone; do not taste a questionable slice to decide.

Storage tips

Safety notes

These pies are closer to leftover egg dishes than to shelf-stable bakery. FSIS shell-egg guidance and leftover rules are the governing ideas; we do not invent a longer counter window when the cold chart says to refrigerate. Not medical advice.

Sources

Related: danger zone · leftovers · all foods